Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings: Paul Pogba sublime and Jesse Lingard continues his scoring streak

We run the rule over the two teams

Monday 01 January 2018 20:40 GMT

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Show all 22

1/22Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Joel Robles - 7 out of 10

Emerged with some credit, matching the majority of what a rampant but forward line could throw at him.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Muhamed Besic - 4 out of 10

Visibly confused by the mere prospect of handling Martial. This was not the day to be making you first go of playing right-back.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Phil Jagielka - 5 out of 10

Not ‘medically fit’ for this game according to Roberto Martinez. However you want to put it, he was off-the-pace.

2016 Getty Images

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

John Stones - 5 out of 10

Hesitated and then moved far too late to meet Fellaini for the opening goal and, in truth, it was one of several moments where the highly-rated centre-half did not look too sure of himself.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Leighton Baines - 6 out of 10

A restrained, unadventurous performance, but that was largely down to he and his team-mates being penned behind the halfway line. The best of a bad bunch at the back.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Darron Gibson - 6 out of 10

On the wrong end of a cartoonish moment in the first half, when Rashford was allowed to pick his moment to turn and sprint past him. A creditable performance, nonetheless, given his lack of playing time recently.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Tom Cleverley – 5 out of 10

Should have made the most of Everton’s second-half resurgence by burying a chance at the far-post. Questions remain over whether he brings any real quality to the Toffees’ midfield.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

James McCarthy - 5 out of 10

Struggled to get a handle on his midfield opponents and, as usual, showed little more than the odd moment of adventure.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Ross Barkley - 5 out of 10

Everton’s chief outlet on the counter in the frantic late stages but his final ball was found lacking on too many occasion.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Aaron Lennon - 7 out of 10

One of Everton’s brighter players in their dismal first half, as most of their brief forays forward originated with the winger. He could, however, have offered Besic more support.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Romelu Lukaku – 4 out of 10

Where was his touch? If the Belgian’s control had been better, he could have had Everton two-up inside the first 15 minutes, and could have notched four by the end of the 90. Those misses seemed to shake him, which explains the lacklustre penalty.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

David De Gea – 7 out of 10

As quiet an evening as Simon Mignolet enjoyed on Wednesday - until the penalty, that is, which was simply not good enough to beat a ‘keeper of his quality.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Timothy Fosu-Mensah – 6 out of 10

Looked inhibited by the occasion early on, particularly when raised a white flag for his first aerial contest with Lukaku. Seemed to recover but made a clumsy challenge for the penalty.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Marcos Rojo - 4 out of 10

Gave Deulofeu far too much room for the goal. Still yet to prove he is good enough to play at this level.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Daley Blind - 5 out of 10

Struggled to contain Lukaku at times, who often found it easy to roll the Dutchman off him.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Chris Smalling - 5 out of 10

Even he probably does not know why, when trying to block Gerard Deulofeu’s shot, he had both feet off the floor and lead with his right when a left would’ve hooked clear. Ultimately, his own goal didn’t matter.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Michael Carrick - 6 out of 10

Settled into his usual role of ticking possession over in the middle of the park and rarely looked to do anything more ambitious, save a delightful chip over the top late on for Rashford.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Marouane Fellaini - 8 out of 10

His delicate clipped finish for the opener complemented an uncharacteristically neat display. His movement for the goal was just as impressive.

Getty Images

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Wayne Rooney - 8 out of 10

Masterful, surprisingly, in the first half as he flitted between holding midfield and ‘the hole’. Everton, like the press pack, spent a lot of their time trying to put a finger on where he was playing. They only did late on, once he had ran out of gas.

Getty

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Anthony Martial - 9 out of 10

If United were ever to look back on this season fondly, you suspected it would have something to do with the Frenchman. He’s put them into a cup final, he may have to win it for them too.

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Jesse Lingard - 7 out of 10

Lively, neat play to set up his team-mates, particularly the cute backheel to send Rashford through, but lacked composure when presented with opportunities of his own.

Everton vs Manchester United player ratings

Marcus Rashford - 7 out of 10

Terrorised Everton as part of United’s quick, if not so sharp, attacking triumvirate. Like Lingard, guilty of spurning opportunities.

Anthony Martial and Jesse Lingard's fine second-half strikes delivered a first win in five for Manchester United as they lifted the gloom of their festive period by beating Everton 2-0.

Jose Mourinho's men had signed off 2017 by exiting the Carabao Cup to Championship side Bristol City prior to three successive draws, yet a stirring second-half performance at Goodison Park on New Year's Day meant they got back on track.

Following a dull first 45, Martial, playing up front in the absence of injured duo Romelu Lukaku and Zlatan Ibrahimovic, curled home a 57th-minute opener before Lingard smashed in his seventh goal in nine games nine minutes from time.

It was Wayne Rooney, United's all-time record scorer, who lost the ball in the build-up to Martial's strike and the 32-year-old endured an evening to forget having been booked and taken off as the hosts lost control of the contest in the second period.

Neither side could lay claim to dominance in the fragmented early stages, with both guilty of ponderous build-ups that missed end products.

But United were always in control and fully deserved their win.

Check the gallery above to find out how we rated players from both teams.

Agree? Disagree? Let us know in the comments below.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies