Raheem Sterling's volley saved a point for Manchester City on a difficult night against Everton .
Wayne Rooney had the perfect return to Manchester, scoring the goal - his 200th in the Premier League - to put Everton ahead against his old rivals.
But Sterling's thunderous volley from the edge of the box at the end of the game was enough to ensure the points were shared.
It was a home debut to forget for Kyle Walker, who was sent off for two yellows inside the first 45 minutes.
Morgan Schneiderlin was also sent off for his second caution late on.
But who impressed and who flopped under the lights at the Etihad? Andy Dunn was watching on...
MANCHESTER CITY
Ederson 5
Go into a serious tangle for the Rooney goal. Unconvincing
Kompany 5
Was a little static at times, not at the top of his game
Stones 6
Not overly-taxed but ttill yet to truly convince in a City shirt
Otamendi 6
Brought most to the party when he tried twice from range
Walker 5
Sent off. Second yellow was a little harsh but lost his discipline
Fernandinho 7
Usual combative self and did a lot of unselfish graft
Sane 5
Very little came off and at fault in build-up to Rooney’s goal
De Bruyne 6
Looked one of the likelier characters to cause Everton trouble
Silva 7
Always the most creative and unlucky with a strike against the post
Aguero 6
Effervescent but unusually hesitant with a couple of opportunities
Jesus 5
One of the poorest performances of his brief City career
SUBS
Sterling (Jesus 46 mins) 7
Danilo (Stones 65 mins) 6
B Silva (Sane 69 mins) 7
EVERTON
Pickford 7
No better distributor of possession in his position. Top keeper
Keane 8 MOTM
Brings a cool head to affairs and looks a great addition
Williams 7
No messing about, just good, solid, no-nonsense defending
Jagielka 7
Amazingly, looks to have regained a yard or two of pace
Holgate 6
Had his hands full but generally coped pretty well
Schneiderlin 6
Sent off. Had to tread carefully after cynical early foul on Aguero - and didn't last the game
Gueye 7
Tireless tackling performance, so often breaking up play
Baines 7
Several brilliantly-timed challenges, used all his experience
Davies 6
Booked. Cautioned early for diving but didn’t curb his tenacity
Calvert-Lewin 6
Played his part in Rooney’d goal and Walker’s dismissal
Rooney 7
Laboured early on but his game intelligence shone for his goal
SUBS
Klaasen (Williams 61 mins) 6
Sigurdsson (Davies 61 mins) 6
Besic (Rooney 90 mins)