This a bleak mid-winter for Jose Mourinho, overshadowed by his old nemesis across town and unable to wake his Manchester United team from the slumber of mediocrity in which they find themselves, drawing games they have to win as the title race pulls away from them.
If Manchester City win at Selhurst Park on Sunday then the gap from United to Pep Guardiola’s runaway leaders will be 17 points after 21 games played, a monumental lead and, all told, an embarrassment to their city rivals who once marched them win for win. This was the third consecutive Premier League draw for United, who have now given up second place to Chelsea and are playing in front of a home crowd who can barely hide their anxiety.
As for the United manager, he was spying injustice once again, and lots of it – this time the failure of Craig Pawson to award a penalty for Maya Yoshida’s handball. It was true that the Japanese defender later conceded he may have got away with this one but if these are the margins that Mourinho thinks separate his team from being one worthy of challenging for the title then he is mistaken.
They are a ponderous bunch, slow to attack and sometimes wide open in defence where David De Gea made three saves including a superb second half stop from Shane Long who has not scored in 33 games including this one. A bad injury to Romelu Lukaku, around the head and neck area, who was carried off after 12 minutes following a collision with Wesley Hoedt, meant that Mourinho is losing attacking players.
He said that Zlatan Ibrahimovic is out for another month with a knee injury related to his cruciate ligament and even chasing the game, Mourinho made only two substitutions. Yet if he was citing video footage in support of his case for the Yoshida handball, he may also wish to take a look at Ashley Young’s elbow into the belly of Dusan Tadic which may be revisited by the Football Association.
On BT Sport, Paul Scholes’ analysis took in the bigger picture, asking whether Mourinho’s team had lost their way. “United look a tired team, they look like they have played 50 or 60 games this season already and we are half way through. I know the crowd were quiet but you have to give them something. They gave them absolutely nothing, it was dead out there.
“I swear to God, they need to liven up, this team, because top four isn’t even guaranteed from this moment. You have got some good teams in there - Tottenham, Liverpool, Arsenal - and they will all be challenging.”
The big call on selection was made by Mauricio Pellegrino who left out his first-choice goalkeeper Fraser Forster in favour of Alex McCarthy, a decision presumably designed to show the England international that he could not take his place for granted. It had been a bad run for Southampton and Forster’s form has been just one of many concerns that required drastic action.
Asked afterwards whether McCarthy was now his first choice, Pellegrino offered no certainties. “In football nothing is fixed. Everything is changing all the time. The reality today will change tomorrow. I try to use the moment [form] of the player, after that they have to use their possibility on the pitch.” It was not a straight answer to who will play against Crystal Palace on Tuesday but a clean sheet should give McCarthy the chance to play again.
United will surely face Everton on Monday without Lukaku, carried off after treatment with his neck supported and an oxygen mask on his face. He was assessed at the stadium with an ambulance on stand-by. By that point he had already missed one of his team’s best chances. Paul Pogba picked out Juan Mata on the right and he crossed into Lukaku, unmarked in front of goal, where the striker headed over.
The 23-year-old Dutch international Hoedt, signed from Lazio on a free transfer in the summer, is the man whom Southampton regard as the natural successor to Virgil Van Dijk. He was superb in the centre of defence including one particularly good challenge on Marcus Rashford, the replacement for Lukaku, when he drove forward on 33 minutes.
De Gea saved twice from James Ward-Prowse in the first half with the home crowd flat and Henrikh Mkhitaryan, back in the side, having a particularly bad evening save one first half cross from the left that Jesse Lingard headed wide of the post. Old Trafford had been singing Anthony Martial’s song long before Mourinho summoned him to take Mkhitaryan’s place on 65 minutes.
On Yoshida’s handball, Mourinho attempted to be measured but subsequently added refereeing decisions from the draws against Leicester and Burnley to his list of grievances. “I watched [the Yoshida incident] on the touchline and on the touchline it looked to me very clear but from 50 metres distance I gave the referee the benefit of the doubt.
“I know my players so when I see people like Mata almost hysterical I understood immediately there was no doubt and at half-time I watched it and it was a penalty like Rashford against Leicester was a penalty, like Herrera against [Manchester] City was a penalty. He is unlucky, I told him that. And I repeat without a problem that the three referees for these three matches – [Michael] Oliver against City, [Jonathan] Moss against Leicester and Craig. They were good referees and good performances. But they have made decisions for us that have punished us.”
Pogba toed in Nemanja Matic’s shot with nine minutes left and Old Trafford roared in relief but the Frenchman was ruled offside and the stadium went back to its quiet worry about the home team as Southampton held out comfortably.