Jump directly to the content
Carabao KO?

Arsenal and Man City could be forced to replay Carabao Cup fourth-round games after making too many substitutions in extra-time

Sponsored by

Paddy Power

THE CARABAO CUP descended into fresh farce with Arsenal and Manchester City dragged into a substitutions probe.

Arsenal needed extra-time to beat Norwich 2-1 and City saw off Wolves in a penalty shootout but both are waiting to discover if they broke rules over subs.

 Arsene Wenger's Arsenal are facing a probe after making two subs in extra-time against Norwich
6
Arsene Wenger's Arsenal are facing a probe after making two subs in extra-time against NorwichCredit: News Group Newspapers Ltd
 Joe Willock was Arsenal's fourth sub of the night against Norwich... and second in extra-time
6
Joe Willock was Arsenal's fourth sub of the night against Norwich... and second in extra-timeCredit: Reuters

The Premier League giants made four changes — two in extra-time — and the Canaries will demand clarification from the Football League.

Four subs are a novelty for cup ties this season but the rules imply only one can be used after 90 minutes.

When asked if Arsenal’s subs had been within the rules, Gunners boss Arsene Wenger said: “Yes.”

Norwich boss Daniel Farke added: “I think the rule has changed but it is complicated.”

Norwich staff were talking about the rule after the game but Wolves, who held out for a 0-0 draw with City at the Etihad, were unaware of the possible probe.

Carabao Cup Rule 10 states: “Each team is permitted up to seven substitutes of whom not more than three may take part in the match.


BALLS UP Pep Guardiola slams Carabao Cup Mitre football for Manchester City’s struggle against Wolves


“Where any match goes to extra-time each club will be permitted to use an additional sub (in extra-time only).”

But both refs last night — Andy Madley at the Emirates and Kevin Friend at the Etihad — allowed the Prem clubs to make two during the extra period.

 Pep Guardiola made three substitutions after the end of 90 minutes in shootout win over Wolves
6
Pep Guardiola made three substitutions after the end of 90 minutes in shootout win over WolvesCredit: AFP
 Both John Stones and Kyle Walker came on for Man City after the end of 90 minutes
6
Both John Stones and Kyle Walker came on for Man City after the end of 90 minutesCredit: Rex Features

The competition is no stranger to controversy after a cock-up in the second-round draw.

When Alex McLeish and John Salako made the draw, the EFL had to issue a clarifying statement.

Brentford, Ipswich, and Charlton were all given away ties having initially thought they were at home.

Brentford tweeted at the time: “We will be at home to QPR”, before following up with: “Or we might be away, we’re not quite sure!!”.

And the third-round draw was held in Beijing in China at 4.15am UK time.

 Sub Eddie Nketiah scored twice for Arsenal to send Gunners into Carabao Cup quarters
6
Sub Eddie Nketiah scored twice for Arsenal to send Gunners into Carabao Cup quartersCredit: Richard Pelham - The Sun
 Sergio Aguero scored a lovely penalty in the shootout for Man City
6
Sergio Aguero scored a lovely penalty in the shootout for Man CityCredit: AFP
Arsenal’s Mesut Ozil shares amazing drawing of himself by artist Sanil Chitraker
Topics