Jump directly to the content
time is not on our side

VAR was right to rule Danny Welbeck did not foul Cesc Fabregas for a penalty – but timing is everything

Former Arsenal hero Cesc Fabregas went down in the box under a challenge from the England striker in derby

DANNY WELBECK’S tackle on Cesc Fabregas was not a penalty but there’s a credibility issue here.

The game went on for over a minute before it was stopped and the incident was reviewed.

 Referee Martin Atkinson had to make big calls
6
Referee Martin Atkinson had to make big callsCredit: AFP or licensors

There is no definitive length of time specified but as soon as that ball is out of the danger zone, the match should be stopped.

What would have happened if there was a penalty appeal in Arsenal’s box straight after?

Would they have gone back to the challenge from Welbeck?

Martin Atkinson asked the VAR to look at a first-half tackle from Victor Moses on Ainsley Maitland-Niles as he saw some contact.

 Cesc Fabregas went down under a challenge from Danny Welbeck
6
Cesc Fabregas went down under a challenge from Danny Welbeck
 Danny Welbeck's tackle on Cesc Fabregas was not a penalty
6
Danny Welbeck's tackle on Cesc Fabregas was not a penalty
 The ref asked the VAR to look at a first-half tackle from Victor Moses on Ainsley Maitland-Niles
6
The ref asked the VAR to look at a first-half tackle from Victor Moses on Ainsley Maitland-NilesCredit: Reuters

If the VAR had said he might have got it wrong, Atkinson would have looked at the incident on the monitor as it is an opinion — but the referee would have made the final decision.

But if Atkinson had pointed to the spot it would have stood, as it would not constitute a “clear and obvious” error.

 Martin Atkinson could call on camera-assisted officials
6
Martin Atkinson could call on camera-assisted officialsCredit: Reuters
 The new VAR technology was at Chelsea vs Arsenal
6
The new VAR technology was at Chelsea vs ArsenalCredit: EPA


COUT IN THE MIDDLE Inside the exclusive Barcelona retreat home to Philippe Coutinho, Lionel Messi and Luis Suarez



After the game, Chelsea manager Antonio Conte said: ""I'm sure the referee checked this situation [with Welbeck on Fabregas].

"I'm positive [on VAR] because when there is a big doubt it's right to check the decision.

"Everyone wants less mistakes in the game"

And Gunners striker Welbeck added: "I didn't know the VAR referral was for that incident.

"Once I get on the pitch I just want to give 100 per cent.

"We could have nicked a goal but we look forward to the second leg."

Feyenoord goal is ruled out due to late referee VDR decision - giving Vitesse a penalty at the other end
Topics